[TFIP-15] Arkis as Tech Service Provider & Liquidation Agent

Summary

In light of Wallfacer’s failed bid to renew its contract with the DAO, a fresh proposal is needed to economize DAO resources and expand the opportunity set for the DAO.

Arkis has been observing TrueFi DAO for some time now, and we are excited to help. We see TrueFi as one of the essential pillars of the institutionalization of crypto and broader adoption of credit as a vital financial primitive in crypto. In a market dominated by a yield maximization profile, TrueFi plays an essential role at the capital formation layer in accelerating the maturity of decentralized finance. We believe the current status of DAO is an excellent opportunity to band together and connect your expertise with ours. TrueFi Credit formation infrastructure, Arkis’s collateralization and liquidation expertise and infrastructure, credit risk management of Cicada and Adapt3r’s RWA tokenization capability.

Arkis proposes to serve as a tech service provider and Prime Broker/Liquidation Agent for TrueFi DAO, with a one-year commitment and six-month budgeting and review cycles. As of 22/07/2024, we are asking for remuneration of 9 million TRU tokens for the next six months of work.

Overview

This proposal aims to achieve two main objectives: (1) apply for the position of Technical Service Provider (TSP) and (2) establish the roles of Prime Broker (PB) and Liquidation Agent (LA) within the TrueFi DAO to facilitate capital-efficient collateralized lending. As a Technical Service Provider, Arkis will support other service providers within the ecosystem, including Adapt3r, Cicada, and others.

As a PB/LA, Arkis will assist the Credit Risk Manager in monitoring, alerting, and liquidating collateral supporting crypto lending deals underwritten by Credit Risk Managers on TrueFi.

Solution

Prime Broker-like services enhance the credit market for trading firms by implementing well-established financial rules to foster a more stable and secure cryptocurrency financial ecosystem. The DeFi Prime Broker model provides the security of over-collateralized lending with the capital efficiency of the under-collateralization model, restricted to the PB’s ecosystem.

About Arkis

Arkis is a DeFi Prime Broker founded in 2022, backed by gumi Cryptos Capital. We are an in-house team of experts in blockchain, trading, and margining infrastructure.

The Team

  • Oleksandr Proskurin
    • Co-founder and CPO at Arkis
    • More than 10 years of algorithmic trading, HFT trading, and market-making experience and expertise in DeFi asset management. Responsible for shaping Arkis’ product feature line and creating the architecture and risk models for pricing and collateralization inside the Arkis Margin Engine.
  • Aleksandr Kopnin
    • CTO at Arkis
    • Technology Strategist and R&D Executive with extensive experience defining and creating software systems based on emerging technologies. Created start-ups targeting various sectors of capital markets, including decentralized self-custody, digital assets clearing & settlement network, AML, DeFi assets management, and others.
  • Serhii Tyshchenko
    • Co-founder and CEO at Arkis
    • TradFi Portfolio manager at +2B AUM funds for 7+ years and experienced fintech builder.

Arkis 1.0: a transparent, secure walled garden for decentralized OTC loans.

  • Credit Providers: Earn passive yields on their assets with higher native returns compared to other lending protocols, backed by superior security guarantees.
  • Onchain Credit Risk Managers: Deploy capital to designated borrowers in a zero-trust environment, benefiting from real-time risk factor monitoring and instant liquidation signals.
  • Asset Managers: Leverage their collateral (ERC-20 tokens, LP positions, Pendle PT tokens) via Arkis smart contracts to obtain undercollateralized leverage with seamless Direct Market Access through Account Abstraction to integrated protocols.

Arkis team has built a system for safe, zero-trust, and robust credit provision on the Ethereum mainnet. The system includes:

  • A set of smart contracts for safe, traceable funds allocation from Lenders’ wallets to Arkis Liquidity Pools (Deposit System) without any counter-party risk (trustless environment).
  • Set of smart contracts through which Borrowers can interact within only whitelisted protocols and operations (Margin Accounts).
  • A set of smart contracts for deploying capital from Arkis Liquidity Pools to Margin Account with collateral deposit from Borrower (Funds Allocation).
  • A set of smart contracts to liquidate Margin Account positions if margin value drops below a certain level (Liquidation).
  • dApp to facilitate both lend, borrow, and close Margin Account transactions.
  • Arkis Risk Management system assesses each allocated Arkis Margin Account in real-time (24/7) and generates liquidation signals for unhealthy profiles.
  • Arkis Analytics to monitor blockchain events and estimate position values and exposures for allocated Arkis Margin Accounts.

Arkis’s smart contracts system has been audited by Quantstamp and battle-tested on live transactions, facilitating over $5 million in transaction TVL. See the audit report here.

There are several examples of Arkis’s system at work on Ethereum Mainnet:

Arkis 2.0: DeFi-CeFi Cross Margining

The Arkis team has extensive experience in portfolio risk assessment for both DeFi and CeFi assets and deep technical expertise in building credit solutions where both DEX and CEX are involved. Arkis 2.0. calculates portfolio margin by considering both CeFi and DeFi positions—the first Prime Broker capable of knowing when a hedge fund is delta-neutral. The user case might involve using existing TrueFi smart contracts architecture/T-bills product to build out the user case where on-chain collateral is used to borrow funds for CEX trading (market-making activities, for example).

Scope of Work:

Tech Service Provider

  1. Initial Arkis Onboarding and knowledge transfer sessions
  2. Milestone: Pool Launch (Partner Integrations for distribution)
    1. Onboard stablecoin distributors
    2. Amend the rewards model and integrate custom protocols if needed.
  3. Milestone: Token distribution (Distributing token incentives on Arbitrum)
    1. Design & agree distribution model
    2. Implement a target distribution model (farming vs airdrop).
  4. Milestone: Wallet / Interface Integrations
    1. Customize the yielding pool to integrate the CeFi protocol
    2. Add new wallet support
  5. Milestone: Additional L2 deployments / Multichain Expansion
    1. Conduct research of L2 platform and network providers
    2. Add on-chain Liquidation / Liquidation Fund Contracts
    3. Modify TrueFi smart contracts & WebApp to support new L2 solutions
    4. Amend the business logic of TrueFi smart contracts to support native tokens
  6. Milestone: tfBill / Fund Admin reporting
    1. Agree & design Advanced Reporting and Accounting requirements for service providers and lenders
    2. Implement UI for Lenders to get interest accrued for connected wallet

*Roadmap readjustment with regular cadence


Prime Broker and Liquidation Agent

Arkis will be the designated Prime Broker solution for TrueFi DAO’s efforts to deploy credit investments across DeFi. Arkis will build out guarded margin accounts for designated borrowers underwritten by Cicada Partners to facilitate safe credit provisioning on an ad-hoc basis.

Connect Letter of Credit and Credit Vaults to Arkis’ institutional lending desk with a pool of KYC/AML’ed borrowers managed by Cicada Partners. This will involve integrating protocols with strong Borrower-Lender PMF to run through LOC or Credit Vaults.

Prime Brokerage’s walled garden model allows credit providers to increase expected APY. With increased capital efficiency inside the Prime Broker walled garden, borrowers are ready to pay more.

Proposal and Remuneration Model

1-year commitment with 6-month budgeting and review cycles.

  • Roadmap for one year period.
  • Detailed budget for the initial three milestones for six months of work.
  • DAO commits resources for an initial scope of 6 months.
  • DAO estimates Arkis’ performance and delivery after six months of work and decides on further collaboration.

Under this approach, DAO remains flexible and does not take unnecessary risks. At the same time, the Arkis team does not need to put an extra premium on long-term planning and project estimation.

Proposal for the initial six months

  1. 9,000,000 TRU tokens as of 22/07/2024
  2. $1.25 million worth of TRU tokens as of 22/07/2024
  3. Start date 01/09/2024*
  4. Finish date 01/03/2025*
  5. The cost model with the roadmap is attached below

truefi-final.xlsx

*This proposal starts in September, but all dates could be shifted

Base and Performance-based Remuneration for Prime Brokerage Services for the credit transactions to be reviewed on a case-by-case basis in further proposals

  • PB commission or revenue sharing TBD

To ensure transparency and accountability in the scope of work assessment, the Arkis team is happy to provide timesheets detailing the number of hours each employee spends weekly.

Estimates are approximate but represent what we can work with. The final scope of work can be adjusted with the DAO, and an updated budget will be presented based on the current model and assumptions.

Arkis executives mentioned in the proposal are not included in remuneration but are responsible for fully representing DAO’s interests and managing the execution of the milestones.

Final Thoughts

The Arkis team has developed modular smart contracts and an on- and off-chain liquidation engine that can significantly enhance existing lending conversations with borrowers and open new opportunities with riskier credit profiles. The ability to manage collateral provides a valuable risk-adjusted service, allowing the DAO to justify higher fees to lenders.

We are excited to explore synergies between TrueFi DAO, Credit Risk Managers such as Cicada, and our Prime Brokerage infrastructure solutions, which empower lenders in a market burdened by constant liquidity crunches.

Index

Arkis References

Case Study: Arkis <> Cicada test transaction

Overview:
Arkis successfully facilitated a decentralized over-the-counter (OTC) loan in a secure and transparent environment. We enabled a seamless transaction between Edge Capital and lenders, supported by robust risk management from Cicada Partners.

Entities Involved:

  1. Borrower: Edge Capital
  2. Risk Manager & Lender: Cicada Partners & Related Entities
  3. Liquidation Agent: Arkis

Assets Used:

  1. Margin Assets: Wrapped Ether (wETH) and Curve (CRV) tokens
  2. Loan Asset: Tether (USDT)

Loan Details:

  • Loan Value: $500,000 USDT
  • Loan-to-Value (LTV) Ratio: 56%
  • Value of Margin Assets: $393,700

Process Flow:

  1. Loan Request: Edge Capital approached Cicada Partners requesting a $500,000 USDT loan.
  2. Collateralization: Edge Capital provided wETH and CRV tokens, valued at $393,700, as collateral. This satisfied the required 56% LTV ratio, ensuring sufficient coverage for the loan.
  3. Risk Management: Cicada Partners assessed the provided collateral and loan terms. The risk manager ensured the transaction met all necessary risk management criteria, on- and off-chain.
  4. Loan Issuance: Upon approval, $500,000 USDT was disbursed to Edge Capital through Arkis’s walled garden account abstraction and liquidity pools smart contracts.

Yield Farming Activity:

  • Edge Capital utilized the borrowed USDT and the margin assets to yield farm on whitelisted liquidity pools within the Convex protocol. This strategy involved providing liquidity and earning rewards through interest and token incentives, maximizing the returns on the borrowed funds and collateral.

Key Considerations:

  1. Transparency: All transactions were recorded on the blockchain, ensuring transparency and traceability.
  2. Security: Smart contracts facilitated the transaction, significantly reducing counterparty risk and ensuring the integrity of the collateral.
  3. Compliance: Cicada Partners’s involvement ensured that all activities adhered to Arkis’s risk management standards and compliance protocols.

Outcome:
The case study highlights a successful transaction facilitated by Arkis:

  • Loan Fulfilment: The loan was successfully disbursed to Edge Capital, allowing them to leverage additional funds for yield farming.
  • Effective Use of Collateral: The provided margin assets secured the loan and met the required LTV ratio.
  • Yield Farming Returns: Edge Capital engaged in yield farming on the Convex protocol.
6 Likes

Thank you for the proposal! Very cool and synergistic initiative to take advantage of opportunities in collateralized lending and leveraging in-depth underwriting expertise from Cicada.

2 Likes

Note: Cicada Partners and its affiliates hold no economic interests in Arkis, or its related entities.

Summary View

Cicada Partners have been working with the Arkis team for over a year, from first diligencing the technical capabilities and roadmap of the project (along with all of Arkis’ competitor projects), to being a user of the platform. DeFi will never scale without risk-managed credit and the Arkis team provides a range of skills and back-end functionality that can add material value accrual to the DAOs front-end, aggregation, and origination layers.

As such, Cicada Partners are in strong support of this proposal for the following reasons.

(1) Strategic Value Proposition: Improve Risk-Reward to Drive Lender Flows

For those active in crypto-credit conversations, it may not come as a surprise to hear that unsecured credit to crypto-natives remains stuck in the murky shadows of Luna and FTX’s demise. Since Luna’s demise in May ‘22 spawned a chain of collateral shortages, liquidation events, and corresponding bankruptcies, we’ve been collecting data with respect to defaults, recoveries, and secondary trading of liquidation claims. These data have formed the basis for our conviction to help the DAO launch unsecured lines of credit to creditworthy counterparties.

At Cicada Partners, we think about the on-chain investment world through a risk-adjusted yield framework of implied and historic probabilities. Leveraging our data set on defaults and implied recovery values back in 1Q24, we viewed lending to crypto-native firms decomposed as follows, with a c. 400bp alpha opportunity available for willing Lenders:

Chart 1:

While crypto-native yields have come down c. 100-250bps since the time the above chart was produced, off-chain credit spreads in the high yield bond market (where probabilities of default and recovery values are in fact deteriorating counter-cyclically to crypto credit) have come down c. 50bps, with single-B credit spreads (our view of the closest LGD comparable that is a, reasonably, tradable index) near lows not seen since before the GFC (!). As such, the relative return opportunity of taking on-chain/crypto risk remains very sound.

Chart 2:

And yet, flows into TrueFi and its competitors have remained subdued because two problems remain: (1) The bulk of crypto curious lender capital looking to deploy into yield-bearing opportunities remains outside of DeFi, and (2) the means of attracting this capital and non-crypto native capital requires additional investment to further improve risk-adjusted returns.

As a consequence, over the past year we’ve engaged in various initiatives to improve the fundamental credit proposition of crypto-lending by focusing on downside protection to improve risk-reward. Chart 3 below provides a view on Collateralized Lending from our 1Q24 research. Key assumptions underlying this chart are the improvement of recovery values to 85% vs. 30% in the case of unsecured, but offset by incremental counterparty risk (assumes 150bps below, but wide variability) due to reliance on third-party custodians or smart contracts. Despite the incremental operational risk, one can see a 100-150bps improvement in our Alpha estimates for collateralized crypto lending vs. uncollateralized crypto lending. As such, if the Arkis team can deliver a more efficient means of collateralizing lending positions, the DAO can materially improve LOCs and Credit Vaults to the target borrower audience, better positioning TrueFi’s products to both grow organically and take market share over time.

Chart 3:

(2) Better Value for the Money: Dollar Comparison of Tech Service Provider

In addition to the strategic value proposition Arkis brings to the table, we’d like to also highlight the proposal in terms of value for the money. Arkis has a large team of engineers and three executives. Based on our conversations with the team, they will look to hire additional members to take the pure engineering team to nine, excluding three technical executives focused more on commercialization. Ignoring those three executives, you will see how costs per head compare quite favorably vs. prior proposals. Net-net, the DAO is getting a team with valuable skills, building products with a complementary use case, and at a fraction of the existing cost base.

Chart 4.

Conclusion

Simple ideas scale, overly complicated use cases drown in deep explanations with lenders. Arkis’ proposal is simple, they can help bring more capital-efficient collateralized lending to the DAO while also support assuming TrueFi’s service provider responsibilities.

Cicada Partners endorses this proposal.

1 Like

Thanks @serjxyz for the proposal. I think the introduction of under-collateralized lending to TrueFi is long overdue as it can reduce the risk exposure that our lenders face. I’m excited to learn more about this offering.

But before diving into this proposal, it’s imperative to note that TrueFi is currently undergoing a vital governance revision. I ask that this proposal not be moved to a vote until further announcements are made and the corresponding upcoming meta-governance proposals are concluded.

Thanks again for your cooperation and for presenting us with this proposal.

4 Likes

I second this

As mentioned by @TylerEther. Kindly wait for updates on vital governance revisions before moving this proposal to vote, the revisions may, or may not, potentially impact the proposals current form.

5 Likes

I would also re-iterate to kindly wait until certain governance items are overhauled, which will also affect the proposal process itself.

4 Likes

The “Allocation” link should redirect here: Ethereum Transaction Hash (Txhash) Details | Etherscan

We appreciate the initial comments and responses. Just to clarify, we were aware of possible governance changes due to recent events, but we wanted to allow everyone enough time to review TFIP-15 thoroughly and gather community feedback and support. We are willing to be patient and will happily adhere to the revised governance process once the community is prepared.

3 Likes